Simple One Gen 2 vs Ather 450X: Which One Wins?

Simple Energy recently launched the Simple One Gen 2 e-scooter in India. At Rs 1,69,999 (ex-showroom, Delhi), it rivals the Ather 450X 3.4kWh variant, and here’s how they compare in terms of their specs:

Battery Pack & Motor 

The impressive claimed range of 265km, offered by the Simple One Gen 2 is one of its biggest advantages. Compared to the Ather 450X, it delivers about 104km more range, which is quite significant, and should make a noticeable difference in day-to-day usage. The Simple One Gen 2 also offers a higher top speed, and is quicker to 40kmph, making it a good choice for riders who want exciting performance. While the Ather 450X takes less time to charge up to 80 percent, when you factor in its shorter range, the faster charging time does not make much sense.

Underpinnings 

Both e-scooters are largely similar in terms of their underpinnings. They come with similar frame types, suspension setups, and braking hardware, and both run on 12-inch alloy wheels. The key difference here is the wider rear tyre on the Ather 450X, which should make it feel slightly grippier in corners compared to the narrower rear tyre on the Simple One Gen 2.

Dimensions

The Ather 450X features a shorter wheelbase, which should make it feel more agile, and flickable in city traffic. In contrast, the Simple One Gen 2 has a longer wheelbase, which should translate to a slightly more stable highway ride at higher speeds.

Another notable difference between the two e-scooters is their kerb weight. The Ather 450X is 17.4kg lighter than the Simple One Gen 2, which is a significant margin for a scooter. This lower weight, combined with the shorter wheelbase, should make the Ather easier to ride and manage in urban conditions.

Features

Both e-scooters are well-equipped in terms of features. The Simple One Gen 2 offers larger underseat storage than the Ather, making it more convenient for carrying groceries. Just like the Ather 450 Apex and Ather Rizta, the brand recently introduced its 'Infinite Cruise' feature on the 450X as well. Both of the cruise control systems, on these e-scooters work quite similarly, and makes using cruise control a lot easier and hassle free.

Price And Verdict

All prices ex-showroom, Delhi.

In conclusion, while the new Simple One Gen 2 is only Rs 4,952 more expensive than the Ather 450X, it offers a significantly better claimed range and stronger overall performance figures. Although both scooters are neck and neck in terms of features, the Simple One edges ahead with marginally better equipment and a larger underseat storage. That said, Ather’s biggest advantage remains its widespread sales and service network, which Simple Energy is still working to match.